Dan Bishop resells timeshare-owner opt-ins off smarttimeshareowner.com in five tiers, from real-time exclusive at $40 down to six-month-old semi-direct at $1.50. The question isn't which tier is cheapest — it's whether any tier clears the $2,998 package after dialing labor and lead cost. This memo sizes that.
One thousand opt-in leads were worked Nov 3–13. That gives us a real contact rate — and nothing else. There is no measured close rate yet, because no sales are logged against that book. Everything downstream of the conversation is an assumption.
Two denominators, deliberately. Dial-level logging (one full calling block: 19.5% voicemail, 11.1% dead numbers) puts human contact at 18.9%; record-level dispositions put it at 32.3% of records that have any outcome logged. Real contact sits in that band, and the tier assumptions below (32% fresh → 6% at six months) bracket it. That book was an aged, unverified opt-in list of unknown vintage — treat 18.9% as the aged-tier floor, not as a guide to fresh exclusive leads.
| Tier | Lead age | Price / lead | Supply |
|---|---|---|---|
| Exclusive live (1st position) | real-time, 25-min order | $40.00 | Capped at 5/day |
| 2nd position | 1 month old (after exclusivity closes) | $17.50 | Open |
| 3rd position | 2 months old | $12.50 | Open |
| 4th position | 3 months old | $4.00 | Open |
| Semi-direct | 6 months old | $1.50 | Open, bulk |
Confirmed by Bricks 2026-11-18: exclusive live is the 1st position — there is no separate "1st position" tier. The ladder runs exclusive → 2nd (1 month) → 3rd (2 months) → 4th (3 months) → semi-direct (6 months). Still worth confirming with Dan whether aged inventory rolls down tier-to-tier or comes from separate pools.
Operating cost per lead is not just the sticker. At 2.5 attempts per record, 25 dials per hour, and $15/hr labor, each lead carries $1.68 of loaded dialing cost ($0.60 labor + $0.07 telephony per dial). On a $1.50 lead that overhead is more than the lead itself — the real cost of cheap inventory is telephone time, not data.
| Tier | $/lead | Contact | Lead→close | Closes/1k | Cost per close | Gross / close | ROI | × to break even |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Exclusive (1st pos.) | $40.00 | 32% | 1.07% | 10.8 | $3,876 | −$1,468 | -38% | 1.61× |
| 2nd position | $17.50 | 22% | 0.68% | 6.8 | $2,830 | −$422 | -15% | 1.18× |
| 3rd position | $12.50 | 16% | 0.45% | 4.5 | $3,164 | −$756 | -24% | 1.31× |
| 4th position | $4.00 | 10% | 0.25% | 2.5 | $2,252 | $156 | 7% | 0.94× |
| Semi-direct | $1.50 | 6% | 0.13% | 1.3 | $2,362 | $46 | 2% | 0.98× |
Base case assumes 28% of conversations reach a real presentation and 8–12% of those close, tapering with lead age. At base, only 4th position and semi-direct clear water ($156 and $46 per close); exclusive needs 1.61× its assumed conversion just to stop losing money.
Lead→close rate. At $40 a lead you need 1.73% (19.3% of conversations) to break even. At $1.50 a lead you need 0.13%. Price per lead changes the bar, not the game. We do not currently know our bar.
Across a 0.4×–3.0× range on close rate, holding contact rates fixed. Green is money, red is a donation.
| Tier | 0.4× | 0.6× | 0.8× | 1.0× | 1.5× | 2.0× | 3.0× |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Exclusive (1st pos.)$40.00 / lead | −$7,282 | −$4,052 | −$2,437 | −$1,468 | −$176 | $470 | $1,116 |
| 2nd position$17.50 / lead | −$4,666 | −$2,308 | −$1,129 | −$422 | $522 | $993 | $1,465 |
| 3rd position$12.50 / lead | −$5,502 | −$2,865 | −$1,547 | −$756 | $299 | $826 | $1,353 |
| 4th position$4.00 / lead | −$3,222 | −$1,345 | −$407 | $156 | $907 | $1,282 | $1,657 |
| Semi-direct$1.50 / lead | −$3,498 | −$1,529 | −$545 | $46 | $833 | $1,227 | $1,621 |
The aged tiers are flat-lined near zero because dial labor, not lead price, is the cost driver. Cheap leads don't create margin — they create dial hours.
| Plan | Scenario | Leads | Closes | Lead spend | Dial cost | Net revenue | Gross | Margin |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A · Exclusive onlyRide the 5/day cap. Highest intent, highest price. 5 leads/day · 15 dial-hrs/mo |
Conservative 0.6× | 150 | 1.0 | $6,000 | $251 | $2,330 | −$3,921 | -168% |
| Base 1.0× | 150 | 1.6 | $6,000 | $251 | $3,883 | −$2,368 | -61% | |
| Upside 2.0× | 150 | 3.2 | $6,000 | $251 | $7,766 | $1,515 | 20% | |
| B · Aged-heavy volume4th + semi-direct. Cheapest leads, most dial hours. 340 leads/day · 1,020 dial-hrs/mo |
Conservative 0.6× | 10,200 | 9.9 | $21,300 | $17,085 | $23,942 | −$14,443 | -60% |
| Base 1.0× | 10,200 | 16.5 | $21,300 | $17,085 | $39,735 | $1,350 | 3% | |
| Upside 2.0× | 10,200 | 33.1 | $21,300 | $17,085 | $79,657 | $41,272 | 52% | |
| C · Blended (recommended)Touches every tier, sized to 2 dialer seats. 100 leads/day · 300 dial-hrs/mo |
Conservative 0.6× | 3,000 | 4.9 | $17,415 | $5,025 | $11,701 | −$10,739 | -92% |
| Base 1.0× | 3,000 | 8.1 | $17,415 | $5,025 | $19,462 | −$2,978 | -15% | |
| Upside 2.0× | 3,000 | 16.2 | $17,415 | $5,025 | $38,958 | $16,518 | 42% |
Plan C is sized to 2 dialer seats at 160 hrs/month (106.7 leads/day ceiling) — capacity binds before supply does. Semi-direct at 300+ leads/day would need ~6 seats to exhaust, which is its own hire.
The offer price scales net revenue linearly, but it moves the break-even conversion rate inversely — and that's what decides whether leads are affordable. Every $500 of average ticket is worth $460 of net revenue per close. Everything else in the model is held constant here.
| Tier — gross profit per close | $2,000 | $2,500 | $3,000 | Break-even ticket |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Exclusive (1st pos.)$40.00 / lead · CAC $3,876 | −$2,386 | −$1,926 | −$1,466 | $4,594 |
| 2nd position$17.50 / lead · CAC $2,830 | −$1,340 | −$880 | −$420 | $3,456 |
| 3rd position$12.50 / lead · CAC $3,164 | −$1,674 | −$1,214 | −$754 | $3,820 |
| 4th position$4.00 / lead · CAC $2,252 | −$762 | −$302 | $158 | $2,828 |
| Semi-direct$1.50 / lead · CAC $2,362 | −$872 | −$412 | $48 | $2,948 |
CAC does not move with ticket price, so the whole table is a straight vertical shift. At $2,000 every tier loses money at base conversion and 4th position needs 1.51× the assumed close rate to break even. At $3,000 the same book is $158 on 4th and $48 on semi-direct.
| Plan | Scenario | $2,000 | $2,500 | $3,000 | Break-even ticket |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| B · Aged-heavy volume340 leads/day · $38,385/mo all-in | Conservative 0.6× | −$23,571 | −$18,998 | −$14,425 | |
| Base 1.0× | −$13,800 | −$6,210 | $1,380 | ||
| Upside 2.0× | $10,901 | $26,117 | $41,333 | ||
| C · Blended (recommended)100 leads/day · $22,440/mo all-in | Conservative 0.6× | −$15,200 | −$12,965 | −$10,730 | |
| Base 1.0× | −$10,398 | −$6,681 | −$2,963 | ||
| Upside 2.0× | $1,664 | $9,106 | $16,548 | ||
| A · Exclusive only5 leads/day · $6,251/mo all-in | Conservative 0.6× | −$4,810 | −$4,365 | −$3,920 | |
| Base 1.0× | −$3,849 | −$3,107 | −$2,365 | ||
| Upside 2.0× | −$1,446 | $37 | $1,521 |
At $2,000 only the upside case on aged volume earns anything ($10,901/mo) — and that requires the entire aged ladder to convert at 2× base. At $3,000 the same plan earns $41,333 upside and $1,380 at base.
At base conversion, nothing in this book works below a $2,948 average ticket — not the cheap leads, not the fresh ones. Exclusive needs $4,594 per close to stand on its own. If the market won't pay ~$2,950, the lead-buy model is dead on arrival regardless of which tier we buy, and the answer is a higher-ticket or recurring offer — not cheaper data.
| Scenario | Expected closes | Gross @ $2,000 | Gross @ $2,500 | Gross @ $3,000 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Conservative 0.6× | 0.68 | −$3,380 | −$3,067 | −$2,754 |
| Base 1.0× | 1.13 | −$2,696 | −$2,176 | −$1,657 |
| Upside 2.0× | 2.26 | −$1,012 | $27 | $1,067 |
Same 105 leads, same script — the only variable is what we charge. At $2,000 the test can't pay for itself even when it beats base by 2×; the upside case is still underwater. That's the cleanest argument for a price floor: the test is only worth running if the ticket is.
105 leads resolves close rate only to about ±1.0pp. Enough to kill a fatally broken funnel, not enough to prove a winner. Treat as a smoke test, not validation. What it does prove: whether Dan's leads answer, whether the pitch survives first contact, and whether the 25-minute delivery window is real.
Approve $4,200 for the exclusive smoke test + ~40 dial-hours of seat time, with the volume decision deferred to the read-out. Everything past that is contingent on a measured close rate.