Forged AI Lead-buy projections Name & startup costs Download PDF
Forged AI Solutions · Internal Memo

Timeshare Lead Buying:
Unit Economics & Projections

Dan Bishop / Real Time Leads & Marketing (smarttimeshareowner.com) — does buying lead volume produce profitable clients at the $2,998 package?
Prepared forAnthony
Prepared byBricks — pricing from Dan Bishop, modeling by Thompson
DateNovember 18, 2026
StatusDecision memo — no spend committed

01The question

Dan Bishop resells timeshare-owner opt-ins off smarttimeshareowner.com in five tiers, from real-time exclusive at $40 down to six-month-old semi-direct at $1.50. The question isn't which tier is cheapest — it's whether any tier clears the $2,998 package after dialing labor and lead cost. This memo sizes that.

02What we actually know

One thousand opt-in leads were worked Nov 3–13. That gives us a real contact rate — and nothing else. There is no measured close rate yet, because no sales are logged against that book. Everything downstream of the conversation is an assumption.

Leads worked
590
of 1000 · 416 marked called
Human contact measured
18.9%
36 humans / 190 logged dials — floor
Answered, of logged outcomes
32.3%
64 of 198 — ceiling
Flagged interested
65
11.0% of worked leads

Two denominators, deliberately. Dial-level logging (one full calling block: 19.5% voicemail, 11.1% dead numbers) puts human contact at 18.9%; record-level dispositions put it at 32.3% of records that have any outcome logged. Real contact sits in that band, and the tier assumptions below (32% fresh → 6% at six months) bracket it. That book was an aged, unverified opt-in list of unknown vintage — treat 18.9% as the aged-tier floor, not as a guide to fresh exclusive leads.

03Dan's price sheet

TierLead agePrice / leadSupply
Exclusive live (1st position)real-time, 25-min order$40.00Capped at 5/day
2nd position1 month old (after exclusivity closes)$17.50Open
3rd position2 months old$12.50Open
4th position3 months old$4.00Open
Semi-direct6 months old$1.50Open, bulk

Confirmed by Bricks 2026-11-18: exclusive live is the 1st position — there is no separate "1st position" tier. The ladder runs exclusive → 2nd (1 month) → 3rd (2 months) → 4th (3 months) → semi-direct (6 months). Still worth confirming with Dan whether aged inventory rolls down tier-to-tier or comes from separate pools.

04The deal math

Package price
$2,998
one-time
Refund + chargeback reserve
8%
$240 held back
Fulfillment cost
$350
delivery, hosting, support
Net revenue / close
$2,408
what a sale is actually worth

Operating cost per lead is not just the sticker. At 2.5 attempts per record, 25 dials per hour, and $15/hr labor, each lead carries $1.68 of loaded dialing cost ($0.60 labor + $0.07 telephony per dial). On a $1.50 lead that overhead is more than the lead itself — the real cost of cheap inventory is telephone time, not data.

05Unit economics by tier conversion assumed

Tier$/leadContactLead→close Closes/1kCost per closeGross / close ROI× to break even
Exclusive (1st pos.) $40.00 32% 1.07% 10.8 $3,876 −$1,468 -38% 1.61×
2nd position $17.50 22% 0.68% 6.8 $2,830 −$422 -15% 1.18×
3rd position $12.50 16% 0.45% 4.5 $3,164 −$756 -24% 1.31×
4th position $4.00 10% 0.25% 2.5 $2,252 $156 7% 0.94×
Semi-direct $1.50 6% 0.13% 1.3 $2,362 $46 2% 0.98×

Base case assumes 28% of conversations reach a real presentation and 8–12% of those close, tapering with lead age. At base, only 4th position and semi-direct clear water ($156 and $46 per close); exclusive needs 1.61× its assumed conversion just to stop losing money.

The one number that decides this

Lead→close rate. At $40 a lead you need 1.73% (19.3% of conversations) to break even. At $1.50 a lead you need 0.13%. Price per lead changes the bar, not the game. We do not currently know our bar.

06Sensitivity: gross profit per close

Across a 0.4×–3.0× range on close rate, holding contact rates fixed. Green is money, red is a donation.

Tier0.4×0.6×0.8×1.0×1.5×2.0×3.0×
Exclusive (1st pos.)$40.00 / lead−$7,282−$4,052−$2,437−$1,468−$176$470$1,116
2nd position$17.50 / lead−$4,666−$2,308−$1,129−$422$522$993$1,465
3rd position$12.50 / lead−$5,502−$2,865−$1,547−$756$299$826$1,353
4th position$4.00 / lead−$3,222−$1,345−$407$156$907$1,282$1,657
Semi-direct$1.50 / lead−$3,498−$1,529−$545$46$833$1,227$1,621

The aged tiers are flat-lined near zero because dial labor, not lead price, is the cost driver. Cheap leads don't create margin — they create dial hours.

07Monthly plans under three scenarios

PlanScenarioLeadsCloses Lead spendDial costNet revenue GrossMargin
A · Exclusive onlyRide the 5/day cap. Highest intent, highest price.
5 leads/day · 15 dial-hrs/mo
Conservative 0.6× 150 1.0 $6,000 $251 $2,330 −$3,921 -168%
Base 1.0× 150 1.6 $6,000 $251 $3,883 −$2,368 -61%
Upside 2.0× 150 3.2 $6,000 $251 $7,766 $1,515 20%
B · Aged-heavy volume4th + semi-direct. Cheapest leads, most dial hours.
340 leads/day · 1,020 dial-hrs/mo
Conservative 0.6× 10,200 9.9 $21,300 $17,085 $23,942 −$14,443 -60%
Base 1.0× 10,200 16.5 $21,300 $17,085 $39,735 $1,350 3%
Upside 2.0× 10,200 33.1 $21,300 $17,085 $79,657 $41,272 52%
C · Blended (recommended)Touches every tier, sized to 2 dialer seats.
100 leads/day · 300 dial-hrs/mo
Conservative 0.6× 3,000 4.9 $17,415 $5,025 $11,701 −$10,739 -92%
Base 1.0× 3,000 8.1 $17,415 $5,025 $19,462 −$2,978 -15%
Upside 2.0× 3,000 16.2 $17,415 $5,025 $38,958 $16,518 42%

Plan C is sized to 2 dialer seats at 160 hrs/month (106.7 leads/day ceiling) — capacity binds before supply does. Semi-direct at 300+ leads/day would need ~6 seats to exhaust, which is its own hire.

08Ticket sensitivity: $2K vs $3K conversion held at base

The offer price scales net revenue linearly, but it moves the break-even conversion rate inversely — and that's what decides whether leads are affordable. Every $500 of average ticket is worth $460 of net revenue per close. Everything else in the model is held constant here.

Tier — gross profit per close$2,000$2,500$3,000Break-even ticket
Exclusive (1st pos.)$40.00 / lead · CAC $3,876−$2,386−$1,926−$1,466$4,594
2nd position$17.50 / lead · CAC $2,830−$1,340−$880−$420$3,456
3rd position$12.50 / lead · CAC $3,164−$1,674−$1,214−$754$3,820
4th position$4.00 / lead · CAC $2,252−$762−$302$158$2,828
Semi-direct$1.50 / lead · CAC $2,362−$872−$412$48$2,948

CAC does not move with ticket price, so the whole table is a straight vertical shift. At $2,000 every tier loses money at base conversion and 4th position needs 1.51× the assumed close rate to break even. At $3,000 the same book is $158 on 4th and $48 on semi-direct.

Monthly gross profit by plan and ticket

PlanScenario$2,000$2,500$3,000Break-even ticket
B · Aged-heavy volume340 leads/day · $38,385/mo all-inConservative 0.6×−$23,571−$18,998−$14,425
Base 1.0×−$13,800−$6,210$1,380
Upside 2.0×$10,901$26,117$41,333
C · Blended (recommended)100 leads/day · $22,440/mo all-inConservative 0.6×−$15,200−$12,965−$10,730
Base 1.0×−$10,398−$6,681−$2,963
Upside 2.0×$1,664$9,106$16,548
A · Exclusive only5 leads/day · $6,251/mo all-inConservative 0.6×−$4,810−$4,365−$3,920
Base 1.0×−$3,849−$3,107−$2,365
Upside 2.0×−$1,446$37$1,521

At $2,000 only the upside case on aged volume earns anything ($10,901/mo) — and that requires the entire aged ladder to convert at 2× base. At $3,000 the same plan earns $41,333 upside and $1,380 at base.

The floor

At base conversion, nothing in this book works below a $2,948 average ticket — not the cheap leads, not the fresh ones. Exclusive needs $4,594 per close to stand on its own. If the market won't pay ~$2,950, the lead-buy model is dead on arrival regardless of which tier we buy, and the answer is a higher-ticket or recurring offer — not cheaper data.

09Proposed smoke test

Buy
105 leads
5/day × 21 days, exclusive
Cost
$4,200
lead spend only
Expected closes
0.7 – 2.3
conservative → upside
ScenarioExpected closesGross @ $2,000Gross @ $2,500Gross @ $3,000
Conservative 0.6×0.68−$3,380−$3,067−$2,754
Base 1.0×1.13−$2,696−$2,176−$1,657
Upside 2.0×2.26−$1,012$27$1,067

Same 105 leads, same script — the only variable is what we charge. At $2,000 the test can't pay for itself even when it beats base by 2×; the upside case is still underwater. That's the cleanest argument for a price floor: the test is only worth running if the ticket is.

105 leads resolves close rate only to about ±1.0pp. Enough to kill a fatally broken funnel, not enough to prove a winner. Treat as a smoke test, not validation. What it does prove: whether Dan's leads answer, whether the pitch survives first contact, and whether the 25-minute delivery window is real.

10Risks

Commercial

  • No close rate. Every projection here is derivative of a number we've never measured. This is the whole ballgame.
  • Resold inventory. If "exclusive" is sold to more than one buyer, contact rates and trust collapse together.
  • Aged-list decay. Six-month opt-ins on a $2,998 pitch produce refunds and chargebacks, not just dials. The 8% reserve may be light.

Compliance

  • TCPA exposure. Timeshare telemarketing is a plaintiff's-bar favorite. Every record needs opt-in timestamp, source URL, and consent language on file — per lead, not per list.
  • DNC scrubbing. Written workflow required before the first dial, and internal DNC retention for anyone who says stop.
  • State rules. Florida and a handful of others add recording-consent and disclosure requirements. Assume the vendor's list is not scrubbed for us.

11Recommendation

  1. Hold the price floor at ~$2,950. At base conversion, semi-direct — the cheapest, best-geometry tier — stops working below $2,948 average ticket, and exclusive needs roughly $4,594. Discounting to $2,000 doesn't create volume, it creates a subsidy.
  2. Don't commit to a volume buy. At base assumptions the offer doesn't carry lead-buy cost at any tier above 4th position — and 4th position only earns 7%. Nothing here justifies $25k out the door.
  3. Run the 21-day exclusive test ($4,200). It's cheap, it prices the one unknown, and it doubles as a script/lab for the aged tiers.
  4. Then, and only then, scale into 4th + semi-direct — that's where the margin geometry is least hostile, provided our measured close rate beats the 0.13% floor.
  5. Fix the measurement before the money. Log every disposition, every appointment, every close in the CRM. Today the book has statuses and no outcomes — we are modeling blind.
  6. Get Dan's answers in writing on exclusivity, consent documentation, refund/credit policy and bad-number replacement before any payment.
Decision requested from Anthony

Approve $4,200 for the exclusive smoke test + ~40 dial-hours of seat time, with the volume decision deferred to the read-out. Everything past that is contingent on a measured close rate.