Net revenue per close
$2,408
$2,998 less refunds and fulfillment
CAC at my base case
$3,876
exclusive — above what a close is worth
CAC at your low case
$651
exclusive at 20% of conversations
Exclusive cap, monthly gross
$16.9k
150 leads/mo at your low case
Cost per close vs. what a close is worth
Base-case conversion, $2,998 ticket. Dashed line = net revenue per close ($2,408); bars above it lose money on every sale.
$0 $1.0k $2.0k $3.0k $3.9k Exclusive $2.8k 2nd $3.2k 3rd $2.3k 4th $2.4k Semi-direct
Only 4th and semi-direct sit under the line — and barely. Exclusive costs $3,876 to produce a $2,408 sale.
Gross profit per close — my assumptions vs. yours
Same lead costs, different close rate per conversation.
My base case Bricks low (20%/5%) Bricks high (40%/10%) −$2.0k −$1.0k $0 $1.0k $2.0k Exclusive 2nd 3rd 4th Semi-direct
Your low end turns exclusive from −$1,468 to +$1,757. That single assumption swings the whole verdict.
Ticket price decides more than the lead list
Gross per close as the average ticket moves from $1.5k to $4.5k, base conversion.
Exclusive 2nd 3rd 4th Semi-direct −$3.0k −$2.0k −$1.0k $0 $1.0k floor $2.9k price $1.5k $2.0k $2.5k $3.0k $3.5k $4.0k $4.5k
Below ~$2,948 the best tier (semi-direct) goes negative. At $2,000 every tier is underwater — discounting is a subsidy.
What has to be true for each tier
Gross profit per close as conversion moves from 0.4× to 3× the base assumption.
Exclusive 2nd 3rd 4th Semi-direct −$8.0k −$6.0k −$4.0k −$2.0k $0 base 0.4× 0.6× 0.8× 1× 1.5× 2× 3×
Cheap tiers cross zero almost immediately; exclusive needs roughly 1.6× base before it stops bleeding — and takes off after.
Monthly gross by plan and scenario
Base assumptions, $2,998 ticket. Zero line is break-even.
Conservative 0.6× Base 1.0× Upside 2.0× −$20.0k $0 $20.0k $40.0k Exclusive only Aged heavy Blended
Aged volume is the only plan that survives a bad scenario — and it needs ~1,000 dial-hours a month to do it.
The funnel at your low case
5 exclusive leads/day for 30 days, 20% close of conversations.
Leads bought 150 Conversations 48 Closed deals 10 $6,251 spend → $23,118 revenue → $16,867 gross
150 leads become 48 conversations and 9.6 closes — $16,867 gross per month from $6,251.
How much room is left in the lead price
Highest price per lead that still breaks even, at your close rates.
Max payable — your low end Max payable — your high end What Dan charges $0 $100 $200 $300 Exclusive 2nd 3rd 4th Semi-direct
On exclusive you have 4–8× headroom. On the one-month tier it's thin: $25–$51 against a $17.50 ask.